Loading...

Is the Opioid Crisis Responsible for the Election of President Trump?

Written by:

at December 16, 2016

Slate.com [Note – this site tends to be left-leaning/liberal] is reporting a researched correlation between those affected and support for Trump. But the causation is still unclear.

According to the research, there seems to be a correlation between places that went heavily for Trump and areas struck hard by the opioid crisis. This has turned up anecdotally, for example, with photojournalist Chris Arnade, known for his “Faces of Addiction” series, saying he “fell into” writing about Trump supporters while documenting addiction. “Wherever I see hope exiting,” he tweeted, “I see Trump and drugs entering.” For Arnade and others, it feels like no coincidence that Trump did best in counties with higher mortality rates.

That’s also what Shannon Monnat, a rural sociologist and demographer at Penn State, found when she analyzed voting data in her recent paper titled “Deaths of Despair and Support for Trump in the 2016 Presidential Election.” According to her analysis, Trump’s margins over Mitt Romney were highest in counties with higher than average drug, alcohol, and suicide mortality rates.

Monnat’s research focuses on the industrial Midwest, New England, and Appalachia. “These places,” said Monnat, “have experienced a perfect storm that facilitates addiction, depression, and suicide,” hence the “deaths of despair” moniker.

Monnat’s findings are part of a larger trend. Last year Princeton economists Anne Case and Angus Deaton discovered that the death rate for middle-aged white Americans, particularly those with a high school education or less, jumped 20 percent between 1999 and 2013—meaning half a million more people died during those years than would have if rates had remained flat. Meanwhile, mortality rates for every other group—even whites abroad—have been declining. (During the primaries, Jeff Guo, at the Washington Post’s Wonkblog, found that “death predicted” a vote for Trump. Wherever whites were dying fastest, Trump performed best.)

Trump’s margins over Romney were highest in counties with higher than average drug, alcohol, and suicide mortality rates.

Ultimately, this connection is just a correlation, with unclear causation. It seems likely it’s a manifestation of another established correlation—between lower economic status and support for Trump (drug addicts are more likely to be of lower economic status). The whys behind many of these correlations are still unclear and may never become clear. Monnat’s paper acknowledges that there is no clear causal relationship between drugs, alcohol, and suicide and support for Trump. “To suggest otherwise,” wrote Monnat, “ignores the economic, social, and demographic complexities that drive human behavior and the contexts of the communities where these voters live.”

Either way, the real question now is whether the president-elect has a serious plan for addressing the woes of these voters. When it comes to the opioid crisis, his own remarks on the campaign trail suggest he thinks building a wall on the Mexico border to be a main solution to the problem. For one thing, the latest opioid making its deadly rounds, illicit fentanyl, is more likely to be unwittingly delivered by mail than it is to come across the border. But more to the point, the wall proposal is a deeply unsophisticated response to this evolving complex public health problem.

Tags:

SOBER LAW NEWS IS A LEGAL WEBSITE PROVIDING NEWS, COMMENTARY AND OPINIONS ON THE ADDICTION TREATMENT AND RECOVERY SERVICES INDUSTRIES. THE ARTICLES REPOSTED ON THIS SITE TAKE AN IN-DEPTH LOOK AT CURRENT TRENDS IN THIS DYNAMIC HEALTH CARE SECTOR AND THE LAWS THAT GOVERN ITS REGULATION AND GROWTH. OUR HOPE AND PURPOSE IS TO PROVIDE RELEVANT AND ACCURATE INFORMATION TO THE PUBLIC AND TO POLICYMAKERS THAT WILL HELP GUIDE THE PROVISION OF ADDICTION TREATMENT OUT OF THE SHADOWS AND INTO TRANSPARENT, MAINSTREAM HEALTH CARE. THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THIS WEBSITE IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND IS INTENDED AS A PUBLIC SERVICE. ANY QUESTIONS OF A LEGAL NATURE SHOULD BE DIRECTED TO AN ATTORNEY, AND THE INFORMATION ON THIS WEBSITE IS NOT INTENDED TO REPLACE LEGAL ADVICE FROM A LICENSED ATTORNEY IN YOUR STATE. BY USING THIS WEBSITE, YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT YOU MAY NOT RELY UPON OR REFER TO THE CONTENTS AS BEING LEGAL ADVICE OR GUIDANCE PROVIDED BY JEFFREY C. LYNNE, ESQ., WITHOUT HIS PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This